The Best Mattress Protectors To Safeguard Your Bed

Mattresses are a pretty big investment, so it’s a good idea to safeguard that investment with a mattress protector. Beyond adding a few years to the life of your mattress, mattress protectors can shield your bed from the potential damage caused by sweat, spills, leaky diapers and/or pet stains. Moreover, mattress protectors are also great for keeping dust mites, pet dander and other allergens in check so you can breathe more easily while you sleep.

The best mattress protectors accommodate your needs and sleeping preferences but don’t detract from the overall comfort of your mattress. After all, you probably spent a good deal of time researching said mattress purchase, and you wouldn’t want to sacrifice that feel with a mattress protector that’s noisy and hot.

To help you narrow it down, we’ve rounded up the best mattress protectors in every category, from the best cooling mattress protector to the best waterproof mattress protector (and some that do it all).

Best Mattress Protector Overall

A Mattress Protector That Does It All

  • Waterproof: yes
  • Depth: 16 inches
  • Material: Organic cotton

Saatva essentially checks all the boxes for a good mattress protector, and that’s why it hits our list as the best mattress protector overall. This mattress protector is made from a combination of organic cotton that wicks away moisture and an ultra-thin polyurethane moisture barrier with micro-perforations that allow for better airflow. The result is a waterproof mattress protector that keeps you cool while you sleep. Saatva’s waterproof mattress protector also has pockets deep enough to fit mattresses up to 16 inches high and a silicone elastic band all the way around, so it won’t shift or move no matter how restless you are.

If sustainability is top of mind for you, it’s worth noting that this mattress pad is Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified, meaning that the manufacturing process, from the harvesting of the raw materials to its arrival at your door, is done responsibly.

Best Waterproof Mattress Protector

A Mattress Protector That’s Waterproof But Still Breathable And Quiet

Best Cooling Mattress Protector

A Mattress Protector That Dissipates Heat

  • Waterproof: yes
  • Depth: 14 inches
  • Material: Cotton terry

While mattress protectors notoriously sleep hot, Brooklyn Bedding’s Luxury Cooling mattress protector turns the heat down. With its proprietary TitanCool fabric, this mattress protector draws heat away from your body to keep you cool while you sleep. And while this cooling mattress protector is quite breathable, it’s still 100% waterproof, so it effectively protects your mattress against all types of fluids and liquids.

Even better, Brooklyn Bedding’s Luxury Cooling mattress protector is hypoallergenic, so it does a good job at keeping dust mites, bacteria and bed bugs at bay. Brooklyn Bedding’s luxury cooling mattress protector also features elasticated corners to keep the mattress protector in place, and it’s machine washable for easy care.

Best Hypoallergenic Mattress Protector

A Mattress Protector That’s Well-Suited To Those With Allergies

  • Waterproof: No
  • Depth: 12 inches
  • Material: Organic cotton

While mattress protectors can certainly protect your investment, they can also protect you from breathing in a host of allergens while you sleep. If you’re sneezing, sniffling and wheezing instead of sleeping, the best mattress protector for allergies is a full encasement, like the Nestwell’s Pure Earth organic cotton mattress protector.

Made from 100% organic cotton, this 6-sided mattress protector forms an excellent barrier against dust mites, pet dander, pollen and other allergens that might be keeping you up at night. Not only does the zippered closure on Nestwell’s Pure Earth mattress protector offer complete coverage of your mattress, but it also allows for easy accessibility when laundering.

Best Organic Mattress Protector

A Mattress Protector That Delivers Comfort And Sustainability

  • Waterproof: yes
  • Depth: 16 inches (default) or 22 inches (deep pocket)
  • Material: Organic cotton and 5% polyurethane

If you’ve invested in an organic mattress, there’s no sense in giving it all back with a mattress protector that doesn’t meet the same standards. If sustainability is important to you, the Avocado Organic mattress protector should be on your shortlist. This mattress protector features a super-thin polyurethane waterproof film (which amounts to only 5% of the total product, well within GOTS standards) sandwiched between two layers of GOTS-certified organic cotton. The result is a breathable mattress pad that’s 100% percent waterproof. And like the mattresses, Avocado’s mattress protector is Made-Safe certified, and Greenguard Gold certified for low emissions.

While this mattress pad was designed specifically for the Avocado mattress, it will accommodate mattresses anywhere from 6 inches to 16 inches high. It’s worth noting that this mattress protector appears quite large right out of the package because the GOTS-certified organic cotton will shrink. (According to the manufacturer, it may take a few washes before the mattress protector fits your own mattress perfectly.) Regular care of this mattress protector is as easy as machine washing and tumble drying.

Best Value Mattress Protector

A Mattress Protector That Delivers At A Fair Price Point

  • Waterproof: yes
  • Depth: 18 inches
  • Material: Cotton and microfiber

The GhostProtector mattress pad from Ghostbed covers a lot of ground as far as mattress protectors go; and at less than $100, it hits our list as the best value mattress protector. Made from a blend of cotton and microfiber, the GhostProtector is soft, breathable and waterproof and has a cooling effect, making it an excellent pick for hot sleepers as well. The GhostProtector mattress pad also forms a good barrier against dust mites, dander and other allergens.

And while you may think all of these qualities would amount to what feels like a suit of armor over your mattress, the GhostProtector, while incredibly effective, is also quite thin, so it won’t affect the overall feel of your bed. Moreover, the GhostProtector will stay where you put it, courtesy of a 2-inch elastic band that runs the length of the mattress pad. Plus, it’s machine washable and dryer-friendly.

Best Budget Mattress Protector

A Budget Mattress Protector With Over 75,000 5-Star Ratings

  • Waterproof: yes
  • Depth: 14 inches
  • Material: polyurethanes

If you’ve already bought a mattress and are now looking for a budget-friendly way to protect your investment, you might consider the Linenspa Premium mattress protector. Made from polyurethane, this mattress protector is waterproof and capable of repelling any liquids, including perspiration and accidental spills. The Linenspa Premium mattress protector is soft and noiseless, and it can accommodate mattresses up to 14 inches high

It’s worth noting that the Linenspa line has quite a few options to choose from as far as mattress protectors go (all of them are machine-washable and dryer-friendly). This one is a top-only mattress protector, but the brand also offers a 5-sided mattress protector. It’s also worth noting that this mattress protector is also backed by over 75,000 five-star ratings on Amazon.


Leave a Comment